Homura did nothing wrong? Yeah right!

"BUT BUT HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG!!"

Yeah, no.

Don't get me wrong, I like Homura. But she ISN'T an innocent lil' angel like the fandom portrays her. She made mistakes and acted irrational, just like everyone else in the show. Like, in one episode, she outright said that she didn't care if Sayaka lived or died, all she cared about was Madoka being happy. She was even willing to kill Sayaka if it meant making Madoka happy (Hello, Homura. Won't killing Madoka's BEST FRIEND make her more sad?).

Also, if she worded her wish differently, she wouldn't have to suffer so much. She could've just wished Madoka back to life and they would've been happy. No resetting over 100 times.

Did I mention how she was the one who caused Rebellion to happen? If she didn't tell Kyubey about the whole Witch system before the Law of Cycles? If she just kept her mouth shut, none of it would've happened.